back to recipes
Tillamook pesto grilled cheeseTillamook pesto grilled cheeseTillamook pesto grilled cheese

Lunch

Pesto Mozzarella Grilled Cheese Sandwich

By: Executive Chef Josh Archibald

This herby twist on the classic grilled cheese sandwich features Brioche or challah bread with butter and olive oil on exterior, sliced whole milk mozzarella and a pesto drizzle on the inside. Serve with a sun-dried tomato aioli, or tomato jam.

15MINserves 2

Ingredients

For the grilled cheese

For the aioli

  • 1 shallot- small dice

  • 1 lemon- juiced

  • ¼ cup sun-dried tomatoes- diced

  • 1 cup Kewpie mayo

  • 1 chive- sliced thin

  • Salt and pepper- to taste

Share:

Make the aioli

  • Combine all aioli ingredients in a small bowl and stir to incorporate. Label and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes to soften the tomatoes, before using.

Make the grilled cheese sandwich

  • Combine 2 tbsp of butter and 2 tbsp of mayonnaise in a bowl.

  • Spread the combination on one side of each of the slices of bread.

  • In a warm pan, on low heat, add half of the olive oil, then the prepared bread, butter/mayo side UP. (See chef note below).

  • Allow the bread to toast until it begins to become golden, Remove from pan.

  • Repeat with the other two slices and remaining olive oil. Wipe the pan and allow it to return to temperature if needed.

  • Return two slices of the toasted bread to the pan, this time with the butter/mayo side down.

  • Add 3 slices of mozzarella too each, and about 2 tbsp of pesto.

  • Add the top bread and cook, slowly, turning and flipping as needed until the bread is evenly darkened and the cheese is fully melted.

  • Remove from heat, cut diagonally, and serve immediately with plenty of the aioli for dipping.

    • Chef Note: Challah and Brioche are similar in recipe in that they both contain fats. Challah is usually oil (to remain Kosher), while brioche is usually butter and egg. Because of this fat the bread will toast nicely and develops a depth of flavor that most other breads cannot achieve. By toasting what will eventually become the inside of the sandwich, we create depth, and an unexpected textural crunch. It is worth the added effort. Also, due to the fats in both bread options, this sandwich will brown faster, and at a lower temperature. Cook slowly, turn often, and stay close to them during the cooking process.

Shop this recipe